I love how, in recent years, horror and thrillers have experienced a resurgence, not only in film but on stage as well. Following the success of Broadway’s Paranormal Activity, another chilling production has made its way to New York’s Off Broadway scene: 2:22 A Ghost Story.
The show takes familiar haunted house tropes, using everything from creepy sounds coming through a baby monitor and the low rumbling of a quiet house at night to the screeching of animals outside and the ominous ticking of a clock in the background. These seemingly ordinary sounds turn a dinner party between friends into an intimate, suspenseful haunted house story and a discussion about whether ghosts are real.
2:22 A Ghost Story was written by Danny Robins, who is no stranger to the supernatural. With projects such as Uncanny and The Battersea Poltergeist podcast, Robins has built a reputation for exploring the unexplained and the possibility of life beyond death. That interest becomes the central theme of 2:22 A Ghost Story, a play that explores belief, skepticism, and the possibility of the supernatural. The New York production is directed by Matthew Dunster and Gabriel Vega Weissman.
Set in a home in a gentrifying neighborhood in London, 2:22 A Ghost Story follows Jenny (Jasmine Cephas Jones), her husband Sam (Finn Jones), and their daughter Phoebe, who is 11 months old. Since moving into their new home, Jenny has become convinced that something supernatural is lurking within its walls. For several nights, she has heard strange noises coming from her daughter’s bedroom at exactly 2:22 a.m. While Jenny fears the house may be haunted, her skeptical husband dismisses her concerns as nothing more than imagination. Determined to get to the bottom of the mystery, Jenny invites Sam’s friend Lauren (Anna Camp) and her new boyfriend Ben (Martin Marquez) over for dinner. What begins as a friendly evening quickly turns into a drunken ghost watch party, as the four friends agree to stay awake until 2:22 a.m. to discover whether something really does go bump in the night.
Setting the Stage for Suspense
Tucked away in the West Village, the Lucille Lortel Theatre offers a different kind of theatrical experience from Broadway stages on 42nd Street. Rather than relying on big set changes, the production takes place almost entirely within one room of a partially refurbished home. The set features a living room, dining area, kitchen, bathroom doors, and a partial view of the staircase leading upstairs. Two sets of glass doors offer a glimpse of the foggy outdoors, with motion sensor lights that add another creepy element to the show.
Two significant features of the set are the staircase leading to the second floor bedrooms and the glass doors opening onto the garden. Several props also play an important role throughout the play, including a stuffed teddy bear and a baby monitor sitting downstairs in the living area, which Jenny becomes fixated on throughout the evening.
I really enjoyed how 2:22 A Ghost Story focuses on the smaller details that can make an ordinary home feel frightening. The smaller setting actually adds to the play’s spookiness. I also love this creative choice because the story revolves around a couple who have recently moved into a new home. There is always something unsettling about moving into an unfamiliar space, especially when you’re left alone. Having the home appear only partially renovated adds to that, creating an unsettling feeling but also an oddly cozy vibe.
Not having access to every room in the house allows my imagination and the audience’s to run wild. We never fully see what might be happening upstairs, leaving much of the suspense to what we hear and what we imagine.
I particularly enjoyed how everyday props, like the baby monitor and teddy bear, become talking points throughout the characters’ conversations about whether ghosts actually exist. And that digital clock? I loved its presence hanging ominously in the background, constantly reminding us of the approaching 2:22 a.m. and the possibility that we might finally get an answer.
When the Scares Don’t Quite Land
If there’s one thing 2:22 A Ghost Story isn’t afraid to do, it’s make its audience jump. While I appreciate a good scare, I’m not particularly fond of jump scares that rely purely on shock value, and unfortunately, this production has a few moments that fall into that category.
The first occurs during transitions between scenes, when a loud scream suddenly interrupts the performance before the music shifts into Massive Attack’s Angel. At this point, the stage lights go completely black, with a red glow illuminating the outline of the stage. While the sudden scream certainly makes the audience flinch, I noticed several people around me covering their ears. This scare just feels unnecessarily loud and hurts the ears more than it creates a genuine moment of terror.
The other recurring jump scares come from the foxes heard outside the house throughout the evening. These are eventually explained as horny foxes that have been bothering the new homeowners. I didn’t mind these moments quite as much, as they at least have some connection to the story. However, given how frequently the scares occur, I wish this element had been explored further in the plot.
My main issue is that a jump scare should serve a purpose beyond simply scaring the audience. One scare that does work comes near the beginning of the play, when Jenny experiences one of her first ghostly encounters (which I won’t spoil). What makes this moment effective is that the scare feels natural to the story rather than an interruption designed to make the audience jump.
For me, that’s where the production is at its strongest. A scare that allows tension to gradually build and is rooted in the narrative is far more effective. Given how much the play succeeds in creating an unsettling atmosphere through its sound design, staging, and performances, I would have preferred to see more of that approach rather than relying on such abrupt moments.
So, if you’re a fan of jump scares or Massive Attack, you’ll probably have a great time with this. If you’re not, I’d brace yourself! Despite this flaw, the rest of 2:22 A Ghost Story is pretty solid.
A Drunken Dinner Party Full of Skeptics, Believers, and Secrets
One of the strongest aspects of 2:22 A Ghost Story is the performances and chemistry between its four main cast members. The ensemble includes Jasmine Cephas Jones, whom I recently saw in HBO’s Lanterns; Finn Jones, known for his roles as Loras Tyrell in Game of Thrones and Danny Rand in Marvel’s Iron Fist; Anna Camp, best known for playing Sarah Newlin in HBO’s True Blood and Aubrey Posen in the Pitch Perfect films; and Martin Marquez, whom audiences may recognize as Gino Primirola in the British comedy drama Hotel Babylon.
What makes the performances particularly engaging is that the tension isn’t only built around the possibility of a ghost haunting the house. Just as much of the drama comes from the friction between the characters and their differing personalities, beliefs, and everyday frustrations.
Jenny, played by Jasmine Cephas Jones, is a new mother who has recently moved into a home where her husband is often away. Jones does a wonderful job portraying someone who is not only frightened but increasingly frustrated. Jenny knows something isn’t right in her home, yet her husband continues to dismiss her concerns. What I particularly appreciated about Jones’s performance is the compassion and love she brings to the character. Even when Jenny is frustrated and feels she isn’t being heard, there’s still an underlying love for her husband.
Finn Jones is insufferable in the best possible way as Sam, an intelligent university professor who embodies the young professional skeptic of the group. Referred to in the show as the walking Wikipedia, Sam is always ready with an explanation for anything related to the paranormal. Sam’s constant mansplaining and condescending attitude perfectly capture the kind of person who believes they always have the answer. Jones does a fantastic job leaning into Sam’s intellectual arrogance and elitism, making him both frustrating and amusing to watch.
Anna Camp is an absolute delight as Lauren, who often finds herself playing Switzerland between Jenny and Sam. A psychiatrist who may have a few hidden motivations of her own for attending the dinner party, Lauren is also drunk for much of the evening, which makes for some entertaining moments. Whether she’s laughing, crying, stumbling, falling, or throwing a drink in someone’s face, Camp is easily the most physically animated performer of the group. I absolutely loved her. She brings so much comedic energy to the production, and her reactions are just as entertaining as the conversations themselves.
Then there’s Martin Marquez as Ben, the oldest and the outsider, with less formal education than these younger, wealthier professionals. Ben is proud of being a hardworking, everyday man, and Marquez does a wonderful job bringing that perspective to the dinner party.
One of my favorite moments involves a séance, which gives Marquez a particularly entertaining opportunity to shine. I also really enjoyed his conversations with the others and the hints at the idea of gentrification. Having lived in this part of London his entire life, Ben has witnessed firsthand how the neighborhood has changed, with newcomers buying up older homes and transforming the area. What makes these conversations interesting is that Ben even begins questioning whether he has somehow become part of the very problem he’s criticizing.
A lot of the comedy comes from the performances of Marquez and Camp, whose characters provide some much needed humor amid the arguments between Jenny and Sam.
Honestly, it’s difficult for me to pick a standout performance because each actor brings something different. All four performances complement one another beautifully. The chemistry between the cast is what makes this dinner party so entertaining to watch, even when the night turns increasingly unsettling.
A Ghost Story Worth Staying Up For
2:22 A Ghost Story has a twist ending that I genuinely did not see coming. I won’t spoil anything, but it’s the kind of ending that leaves you thinking long after the curtain comes down. In fact, it’s one of those shows I’d happily go back and see again, if only to pick up on the little details I might have missed the first time around.
Despite my issues with some of the unnecessary jump scares, I did enjoy the story and found it intriguing, and the ending certainly gave me plenty to talk about. I’d actually recommend bringing a friend along so you can discuss everything that happened once the show is over. After all, that is half the fun of a ghost story, right?
2:22 A Ghost Story is playing Off Broadway at the Lucille Lortel Theatre through January 17, 2027, as part of a limited 13 week engagement. I’d definitely recommend checking it out!
Staff Writer & Media Critic for Big Gold Belt Media: NYC Actress | Twitch Streamer | Artist